Best ice cream in Bay Shore, NY

Top rated

• 1.Häagen-Dazs

  1701 Sunrise Hwy #9118
  4.3136 ratings

Also rated

• Ralph's Famous Italian Ices

  71 E Main St
  4.501 rating
• Baskin-Robbins

  1261 Sunrise Hwy
  4.036 ratings

More shops to try

• American Classic ice cream #8967

  1565 5th Industrial Ct
• Carvel

  188 Howells Rd.
• Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream

  75 Howells Rd