Rated on The Scoop
- Handel's Homemade Ice Cream7212 Fulton Dr Nw4.001 rating
- Culver's4896 Everhard Rd NW3.701 rating
- Bruster's Real Ice Cream4609 Hills and Dales Rd NW2.933 ratings
More shops to try
- 2 Scoopz138 5th St NW
- Almost Heaven Ice Cream6590 Middlebranch Ave NE
- Country Cones4219 Middlebranch Ave NE
- Dairy Queen Grill & Chill4110 Hills and Dales Rd NW
- Heggy's Nut Shop3200 Tuscarawas St W
- Kustard Korner2710 Fulton Dr NW
- Smith's Waco Market - Ice Cream1660 Waynesburg Dr SE
- Smoosh Cookies2101 Hall Of Fame Wy NW
- SugarDaddy4230 Belden Village St NW
- Taggarts Ice Cream1401 Fulton Rd NW
- Tasti Creme4767 Navarre Rd SW