Best ice cream in Cape May, NJ

Top rated

• 1.Ben & Jerry’s

  414 Washington Street
  4.2744 ratings
• 2.Rita's Italian Ice

  707 Beach Ave
  3.7810 ratings
• 3.Kohr Bros Frozen Custard

  2 locations in Cape May
  3.4710 ratings

Also rated

• Peace Pie

  326 Carpenters Lane
  4.556 ratings

More shops to try

• Cione Gelato

  315 Ocean Street
• Dry Dock Ice Cream Bar & Grill

  1440 Texas Avenue
• Fine Fellows Creamery

  313 Beach Avenue
• Kings Ice Cream Parlour

  401 Lafayette Street
• Philadelphia Water Ice

  100 Beach Avenue
• Salty Scoops Ice Cream & Farm Stand

  716 Seashore Road
• Uncle Charleys Ice Cream

  306 Washington Street
• Wooder-Ice

  307 Beach Avenue