Best ice cream in Garden City, NY

Top rated

• 1.Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

  630 Old Country Road
  3.8514 ratings

Also rated

• Cold Stone Creamery

  2 locations in Garden City
  4.202 ratings

More shops to try

• TCBY

  158 7th St
• Uncle Louie G's

  661 Franklin Ave
• Venchi Chocolate & Gelato

  630 Old Country Rd store 1091b