Best ice cream in Middletown, NY

Top rated

• 1.Rita's Italian Ice

  92 Dolson Avenue
  3.7810 ratings

More shops to try

• 25 Below Ice Cream And More

  1 Galleria Dr K 107
• Blueberry Mountain Ice Cream

  655 NY-17M
• Carvel

  130 Dolson Ave.
• Frozen d Lite

  1 Galleria Dr Unit C108
• Michoacana sabor a mexico

  1308 Dolsontown Rd Ste 3
• The Green House Cafe & Gallery

  207 Monhagen Ave
• Y & E Creations

  1 Galleria Dr