Rated on The Scoop
- Baskin-Robbins674 Broadway4.036 ratings
More shops to try
- Mary Jane's Dairy Bar5334 US-9W
- Midnight Ferry12 Front St
- Newburgh Dairy & Grill183 S Robinson Ave
- SweetFrog1217 NY-300
Ranked by the flavor ratings people post on The Scoop. 5 shops in Newburgh.