Rated on The Scoop
- Ralph's Famous Italian Ices153 Main St4.501 rating
More shops to try
- Carvel25 Montauk Highway
- Dolce Scoop Gelato Sayville110 W Main St
- SweetFrog5640-35 Sunrise Hwy
Ranked by the flavor ratings people post on The Scoop. 4 shops in Sayville.