Rated on The Scoop
- Ralph's Famous Italian Ices990 Montauk Hwy4.501 rating
- Cold Stone Creamery999 Montauk Hwy, Unit 194.202 ratings
More shops to try
- Carvel492 William Floyd Pkwy
- What’s the Scoop?60 Surrey Cir
Ranked by the flavor ratings people post on The Scoop. 4 shops in Shirley.