Sugar Hill Creamery

Sugar Hill Creamery serves handmade, small batch ice cream, including non-dairy and vegan ice cream options, with both seasonal and classic flavors available year-round. Many of our ice cream flavors are inspired by our Caribbean and Midwestern cultures, as well as Harlem, our neighborhood of 20 years.

Flavors

• Tuma Buna

  Ethiopian Coffee, Caramel, Ginger, & Tumeric

  Ice cream
  3.401 rating
• Andy Griffith

  Vanilla ice cream.

  Ice cream
• ANDY GRIFFITH (GF)

  Nothing is more vanilla than Andy Griffith.The vanilla for this classic comes from the island, Ile Bourbon, from which the vanilla was originally sourced and not the bottle stashed directly underneath

  Ice cream
• Banana Pudding

  Ice cream
• BROWN BOMBSHELL

  This knock-you-off-your-feet flavor pairs milk chocolate ice cream with swirls of caramel, pecans, and salted pecan blondies. The result is sure to leave an impression that you may not be able to shak

  Ice cream
• Brownie Sundae

  Layered sundae with two scoops of ice cream topped with homemade brownies, chocolate or caramel sauce, and whipped cream.

  Ice cream
• Buggin' Out

  Tastes like a malted vanilla milkshake with clusters of chocolate-covered Rice Krispies and rivers of raspberry coulis.

  Ice cream
• CAFE TOUBA (N)

  Café Touba in its traditional form is a popular Senegalese coffee drink made with Grains of Selim (or Djar) and cloves. We’ve paired it with peanut brittle, peanuts are a Senegalese staple, and cardam

  Ice cream
• Chairperson of the Board

  Blueberry cheesecake ice cream.

  Ice cream
• FAMILY BUSINESS (GF)

  Citrus. Almond. Rum Cake lace this flavor that also includes passionfruit jam. This flavor harkens back to the Good Humor toasted almond ice cream bar, but better because citrus, rum, and passionfruit

  Ice cream
• First Day Out

  Roasted ears of corn and whole jalapenos steeped in the vanilla ice cream base; naturally sweet with a hint of spice.

  Ice cream
• FLY GIRL (GF)

  Named after the movie Honey, which is based in Harlem and the Bronx and was written about former Fly Girl, choreographer Laurieann Gibson, this spring-customer-favorite is steeped for 24-hours in lave

  Ice cream
• General Order No. 3

  Juneteenth flavor inspired by a strawberry sumac cake: cooked-down strawberry, sumac and almond in the ice cream base with strawberry sumac gelee and cubes of cornmeal cake.

  Ice cream
• GEORGE COSTANZA

  Inspired by the Seinfeld episode where George Costanza said he would drape himself in velvet if it were socially acceptable, we feel the same about this ice cream. We fold in red velvet cake pieces in

  Ice cream
• GRAN GRAN'S BANANA PUDDING

  Made in collaboration with Amaya Noelle Higgins of the Mama Foundation for our Harlemites series, Gran Gran’s Banana Pudding is inspired by Marija Abney, founder of The Soapbox Presents–Harlem’s most

  Ice cream
• Green Carts

  Strawberry ice cream twisted with a hint of basil, homemade lemon curd, and nilla wafers.

  Ice cream
• Guava Quesito

  Ice cream
• Habichuelas con Dulce

  Ice cream
• Haitian Hot Chocolate

  Ice cream
• Hello New World

  Cookies and caramel flavor.

  Ice cream
• I Live It, How I Get It

  Cream cheese ice cream base with brown butter cake and lemon curd swiss meringue folded in for a sweet and tart balance.

  Ice cream
• Ice Cream Sandwich

  Build your own from a selection of cookies and brownies and your choice of ice cream from the dipping case.

  Ice cream
• Ice Cream Sandwiches

  Build your own ice cream sandwich from a selection of cookies and brownies with your choice of ice cream from the dipping case.

  Ice cream
• LIQUID SOUL (GF)

  Liquid Soul is our sorrel sorbet, a celebration of the deep, spiced flavors that have long been at the heart of Caribbean gatherings and cherished family traditions. Inspired by the hibiscus-infused d

  Sorbet
• Neneh Cherry

  A subtle, nutty ice cream that packs a pop of cherry with a clean finish. Contains nuts.

  Ice cream
• Nunu's Peach Cobbler

  Ice cream
• ORANGE BLOSSOM SPECIAL (GF)

  Named after the deluxe passenger train connecting railroads between New York City and Miami during the winter months from 1925 to 1953, this flavor pairs orange blossom water ice cream with *gluten-fr

  Ice cream
• Right Thing to Say

  Fresh sorbet combining passionfruit and apricot with mildly spicy guava sauce made by Harlem's own Dr. Sauce.

  Sorbet
• SATURDAY MORNING (GF)

  A tribute to cherished weekend traditions, Saturday Morning is our Haitian hot chocolate ice cream, inspired by the cultural background of our co-owner, Petrushka Bazin Larsen, and her memories of enj

  Ice cream
• Soursop Sorbet

  Sorbet
• Sweet Socialism

  Dark chocolate sorbet.

  Sorbet
• SWEET SOCIALISM (GF)(V)

  The African island of Madagascar provides us with this single-estate dark chocolate. The result is a decadent, rich sorbet often mistaken for ice cream because of its creamy, milky texture.

  Sorbet